Best Poster Award for HSR in Hangzhou

At one of the best-known international conferences in the field of electromagnetic field computation (Conference on Electromagnetic Field Computation CEFC), a former HSR student was able to establish himself against tough competition with the presentation of his Master's thesis. Of the approximately 800 papers presented by researchers from all over the world, six received the "Best Poster Award". Among them, surprisingly, was Thomas Franz from the IET with his poster entitled "Time Domain Inrush Current Simulations of Power Transformers". This conference takes place every two years and was held in Hangzhou, China in 2018.

Background and content of work

The master's thesis, in the field of electrical power engineering, was carried out together with the electricity company of the Canton of Thurgau (EKT AG). This work was mainly concerned with the calculation of resonant inrush currents in power transformers. 

In the substations of EKT AG, there are two power transformers connected in parallel for redundancy reasons. One transformer carries the entire load of the catchment area. The second is disconnected and is only switched on to compensate for faults in the network or to carry out maintenance work. When the first transformer is switched on, voltage dips are recorded on the medium-voltage side of the second transformer, which is already under load. These voltage dips impair the quality of the network and can reach such an extent that even the earth fault detection system triggers an alarm message. There is a risk that the entire sub-area could be disconnected from the electricity grid. End customers such as the Amriswil municipal utility also noticed these voltage fluctuations and this led to uncomfortable queries to EKT AG.

The phenomenon of inrush currents in power transformers is widely known and can be calculated with good accuracy for decades. However, a transformer that is switched on not only generates high inrush currents in itself, but can also lead transformers connected in parallel into saturation. In the transformer that was already in operation, inrush currents are thus also generated. The coupled system thus experiences the effect of the so-called sympathetic inrush current. The theory suggests that the sympathetic inrush currents are the main cause of the original voltage problem. This phenomenon is far less precisely documented than the simple inrush current, especially in compensated medium-voltage networks. Therefore, a detailed simulation model of the substation in EMTP (Electromagnetic Transients Program) had to be created to show the non-linear effects of the switching processes. The main difficulty was the correct modelling of the transformers. To determine the transformer parameters, magnetic field simulations were also carried out using FEM software.

Results

Essentially, it was shown in the master thesis that the setting of the earth fault suppression coil has the strongest influence on the secondary-side voltage fluctuations of the transformer. When the earth fault suppression coil is operated close to the resonance point, this causes the voltage dips as described in the problem definition. As suspected, the reason for this phenomenon is the resonating inrush current.

The graph on the right shows the comparison of the simulated voltages on the medium-voltage busbar with the measurements in the substation.

Furthermore, it was possible to show with transient simulations that the inrush currents can be damped with the help of the tap changer on the transformer in order to minimise the voltage fluctuations on the medium voltage side. 

The results of the transient FEM simulations were then mainly presented at the CEFC conference. The graduate performed these simulations with a commercial software for magnetic field calculations (MagNet by Infolytica). A novel method was developed to take into account the remanence of the transformer core, which is crucially important for the correct calculation of the inrush currents. Using measurement data from the substations of EKT AG, the simulation models could be verified with a good agreement.

The graphs below show the field image of the magnetic flux density at the time of the first inrush current peak (left) and the comparison of the inrush currents between the different simulation methods and the measurement (right).

Conclusion

The frequently mentioned energy turnaround is constantly leading to adjustments and expansions to the distribution grids. Because at the same time the demands on the quality and stability of electrical energy transmission are becoming ever greater, grid operators are faced with major tasks. Support from the universities of applied sciences, as in this example with a master's thesis, can be of great benefit to grid operators in the future.

Contact persons

Thomas FRANZ

IET Institut für Energietechnik Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter

+41 58 257 43 04 thomas.franz@ost.ch

Dr. Jasmin Smajic

IET Institut für Energietechnik Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter

+41 58 257 43 26 jasmin.smajic@ost.ch